A 2024 study by Microsoft and LinkedIn found that nearly half (46%) of working professionals were actively considering quitting their jobs last year.1 Employee turnover doesn’t just come at a financial cost, which can range from half to two times an employee’s first-year salary.2 It also pulls time and focus away from key business priorities.
But high turnover isn’t just about compensation or career advancement. At its core, employee attrition often comes down to one thing: management. One of the top reasons employees leave a job is because of a toxic or negative work environment, which often stems from poor leadership.3
The day-to-day experience employees have with their manager is one of the strongest predictors of whether they stay engaged, quietly check out, or leave altogether. In fact, studies show that anywhere from 50% to 75% of employees leave because of their manager or factors their manager controls.4 The phrase “employees quit managers, not companies” continues to ring true.
When employees feel unsupported, whether they are micromanaged, overlooked, or not truly listened to, disengagement often begins quietly. They start pulling back in meetings, their enthusiasm fades, and their energy for the work declines. While they may still show up, they are no longer fully present. By the time they decide to leave, the disconnect has often been building for quite some time.
How Managers Influence Employee Retention
Managers play a critical role in shaping the employee experience. They impact everything from how connected someone feels to the company’s mission to whether they feel safe, valued, and seen. In fact, one study found that a direct manager has as much influence on an employee’s mental health as their spouse or partner.5 That’s a powerful reminder of how personal the workplace has become and how much leadership matters.
In today’s workforce, mental health, support, and fulfillment often matter more than a large paycheck. Employees want to work in environments where they’re developed, coached, and appreciated, not just managed.
That’s why the role of a manager isn’t just about tracking performance or hitting goals. It’s about creating the kind of environment where people can do their best work. When managers offer clear communication, recognize contributions, and invest in their team’s growth, people stay, even through tough seasons.
On the flip side, when that support breaks down, whether it’s due to a lack of feedback, unclear expectations, or a sense of being undervalued, disengagement begins to take hold.
When employees don’t feel supported by their manager, motivation drops, communication breaks down, and even top performers may begin to pull back. Once that disconnect is in motion, it becomes much harder to rebuild.
Retention isn’t about grand gestures — it’s shaped in the day-to-day. The small, consistent actions managers take to support, guide, and connect with their team are what make the biggest difference.
What Great Managers Do Differently — and Why It Matters
Strong managers don’t rely on gut feeling or instinct alone. They take the time to understand their team, including what motivates each person, how they prefer to communicate, where they excel, and where they may struggle. Just as importantly, they make the effort to understand themselves.
They know how to adjust their approach to meet people where they are. They communicate clearly, follow through, and make space for recognition and growth. They build trust not with big gestures, but with consistency.
Being a manager and understanding each team member’s unique needs isn’t easy, but with the right tools, it’s absolutely possible. Too often, companies overlook this part, focusing solely on hitting business goals without recognizing that employees are the ones driving those results. One of the most common missteps is promoting high performers into leadership roles without equipping them to lead others effectively. That’s where misalignment starts and where things often begin to break down.
Even the most well-meaning manager can create confusion, tension, or disengagement if they’re leading from instinct instead of insight. And over time, those small misalignments can develop into larger problems, such as lower morale, higher turnover, and teams that never quite reach their full potential.
But it doesn’t have to be that way. When managers are equipped with the right tools, they can lead with clarity and confidence, building the kind of team people want to stay on.
Supporting Managers to Lead More Effectively
If we want managers to lead in a way that drives engagement and retention, we have to set them up for success. That means providing them with the right tools, training, and support, rather than expecting them to figure it out on their own.
Utilizing behavioral assessment tools like The Predictive Index, a behavioral assessment that helps organizations understand how people work and collaborate, can be a valuable resource for managers. It offers insight into both their own leadership style and the unique needs of each team member, including how individuals prefer to communicate, what motivates them, and where they thrive.6 Most importantly, it helps build self-awareness, allowing managers to recognize their strengths and potential blind spots so they can lead more effectively and with greater intention.
But insight alone isn’t enough. Companies also need to invest in leadership training and development, especially at the middle management level. These are the people who carry the day-to-day employee experience, and their impact is often underestimated.
When managers feel confident in their leadership and have the right tools to connect meaningfully with their team, retention moves beyond being just a goal. It becomes a natural result of the way the organization functions.
Final Thoughts
Retention isn’t solved by offering more perks or reacting to turnover after it happens. It starts with how people are managed every day — and whether leaders are equipped to support, develop, and truly understand their teams.
The companies that get this right don’t just reduce turnover, they build stronger, more engaged teams from the inside out.
If you’re looking to invest in your managers and strengthen your leadership pipeline, our People Strategy & Hiring team at ClearPath can help. We combine tools like Predictive Index with practical leadership development to help your managers lead with clarity, confidence, and impact.
Let’s build teams people want to stay on and leaders they want to grow with.
Not sure where to start? Contact us today.
- Pomroy, K. (2024, May 16). Nearly 50% of workers are thinking of quitting their jobs, study shows. are you?. Kiplinger. https://www.kiplinger.com/personal-finance/careers/half-of-workers-are-considering-leaving-their-jobs-in 2024#:~:text=Here’s%20how%20it%20works.&text=Nearly%20half%20(46%25)%20of,between%20February%20and%20March%202024 ↩︎
- Heinz, K. (2024, July 17). The true costs of employee turnover. Built In. https://builtin.com/recruiting/cost-of-turnover#:~:text=What%20is%20the%20actual%20cost,%241%2C500%20for%20an%20hourly%20employee. ↩︎
- Person. (2024, November 22). Future of talent retention: Understanding why employees leave and why they stay. Welcome to SHRM. https://www.shrm.org/executive-network/insights/future-of-talent-retention-report-why-employees-leave ↩︎
- Spence, J., & Covey, S. M. R. (2023, October 2). How managers affect employee retention – business leadership today. Business Leadership Today – The resource for leaders working to build and sustain world-class teams and organizations in today’s business environment. https://businessleadershiptoday.com/how-do-managers-affect-employee-retention/ ↩︎
- Business Wire. (2023, January 24). Managers impact our mental health more than doctors, therapists – and same as spouses. Global Press Release & Newswire Distribution Services. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20230124005390/en/Managers-Impact-Our-Mental-Health-More-Than-Doctors-Therapists-and-Same-as-Spouses ↩︎
- Managing. The Predictive Index. (2025, July 1). https://www.predictiveindex.com/software/managing/ ↩︎